Carla+Morton+Rubric

Rubric for Learning Outcome Certification Review Course Carla Morton 0 || 1 ||  3 ||  5 || **Examine the Ethical Dilemma** Does not identify the dilemma. || Identified the dilemma. || Identifies the dilemma including pertinent facts and clearly determines what must be decided. || Describes in details the evidence that was gathered to determine the facts and clearly determines what must be decided. || Does not identify who should be involved in the decision making process. || Identifies who should be involved in the decision making process and who are the key stake holders. || Discusses each of the stake holders’ position and who should be involved in the process and their various value systems. || Thoroughly identifies and discusses the position of each stake holder and their values and how they would like the decision to be made. || Does not identify the alternatives. || Identifies the alternatives. || Identifies and investigates the alternatives including the moral principles that come into play. || Identifies and investigates the alternatives including the moral principles that come into play and also similar approaches from other cases that might support a particular alternative. || Does not make a decision about the alternative. || Determines the best alternative. ||. || Determines the best alternative and describes how the decision maximizes the most benefit and minimizes the risk. Also, defend position as others may challenge it. || || ||  ||  ||